PolicyPulse.pro

New Zealand regulator outlines how resilience investment can benefit consumers

People on a rocky mountain peak overlooking a large lake and snowy mountains
Photo: Photo by Aaron Sebastian on Unsplash

Commerce Commission Chair Dr John Small said infrastructure resilience should be treated as a form of insurance, with investment decisions grounded in evidence, costs and consumer preferences. He also urged regulated providers to collaborate across networks and noted the Commission’s draft resilience principles.

11.11.2026 | New Zealand competition authority


In an address to the Lifeline Utilities Forum in Hamilton on 10 November 2026, Commerce Commission Chair Dr John Small explained why resilience matters to the regulator’s work. The Commission regulates parts of the energy, communications and water sectors, where limited import competition means regulation must help protect consumers’ long-term interests.

Small said regulation must balance affordable prices with sufficient returns to support investment and service quality. Resilience is connected to efficient capital investment, asset management, operational efficiency and pricing discipline. He cited analysis showing that disaster response and insurance payouts across the public and private sectors averaged about NZ$4.2 billion annually over the 15 years from 2010.

Small described resilience investment as a form of insurance: spending now can reduce the cost and disruption of future disasters. Unlike conventional insurance, infrastructure resilience usually involves physical investment and its benefits are shared among many users. Because those benefits are shared, markets may provide too little resilience, while consumers ultimately bear the costs either through investment or through disruption after an event.

Resilience can involve more than hard infrastructure such as network redundancy, spare capacity and flood protection. Small also highlighted green infrastructure, including flood paths and stormwater systems, as well as early-warning systems, emergency response capability, recovery planning and community relationships.

Because infrastructure networks depend on one another, failures can cascade across services. Small called for providers and other organisations to plan together, share information, understand network interdependencies, and coordinate response and recovery. He encouraged regulated organisations to participate in regional lifeline networks and other public-private partnerships involving councils, emergency management organisations, regulators and communities.

When assessing capital expenditure proposals, the Commission aims to allow prudent investment, including resilience measures, while preventing excessive or unsupported spending. Approved costs can be recovered from consumers, so providers should test their assumptions, assess risks and costs, and engage with consumers about the reliability they value and are willing to pay for. Small said the Commission sets incentives and monitors performance but does not run infrastructure businesses.

The Commission has published draft resilience principles, received around 40 submissions and held an open workshop. Small said feedback has focused in part on proportionality and how mature organisations’ resilience approaches should be. He emphasised that sound decisions require robust evidence about risks, costs and benefits, alongside a clear understanding of consumer preferences.

Consult source

Terms of ServicePrivacy PolicyCoverage
LinkedInFollow us on LinkedIn

© 2026 PolicyPulse. All rights reserved.